About Alternative Car Care
Quality Auto Repair Since 1996 | ASE-Certified Technicians | Family Owned
Quality Auto Repair Since 1996ASE-Certified TechniciansFamily Owned
Exceptional Automotive Repair Backed by Experience
Jerry and Cathy, after 23 years in business, feel they provide quality workmanship and parts, and back them with exceptional customer service. Today along with their professional staff, they are proud to say, “We provde exceptional service and workmenship to all our customers."
At Alternative Car Care, our staff has over 75 years of combined experience in the automotive repair industry and we continue to stay on top of the latest technology and procedures. Our certified technicians are able to accurately and efficiently diagnose a wide variety of automotive problems, including wiring issues, instrument cluster warning lights, drivability problems, and more. From the most straightforward repair to the most complex, you can count on our dedicated team to come through for you!
Why Choose Alternative Car Care?
- Quality auto repair since 1996
- ASE-certified technicians
- Auto electrical specialists
- Licensed emissions repair facility
- Family owned
- Pet-friendly shop!

Jerry Old, Owner
Jerry’s automotive career started all the way back when he was 8-years-old fixing his bicycle in his parents’ garage. As a teen, he came to love cars, motorcycles, and basically anything that had an engine. That love lead him to pursue a career in automotive repair. As a testament to his dedication, Jerry trained in high school while simultaneously attending automotive technical school.
Today, Jerry is proud to be an ASE-Master Certified Tech who holds a variety of other automotive certifications. He is also a successful business owner. Jerry's love for the automotive industry continues to inspire him to this day.
Jerry is happily married with two beautiful daughters. He enjoys vacationing with his family, spending the day on his boat, and going to the races.

Cathy Fernicola, Owner
Although Cathy is not a technician, she definitely loves cars. As a co-owner of Alternative Car Care, she manages our daily operations and handles all marketing. Cathy also organizes charity events and donations, including those for Rescue Ridge, a not-for-profit, no-kill animal rescue that she volunteers at.
When Cathy's not at our shop or Rescue Ridge, she enjoys traveling and spending time with her two daughters, four grandsons, and her beloved dogs.

Bill Fullerton, Service Writer
Bill has worked in the automotive field for over 30 years now. He is a true people-person, who's friendly, helpful, and happy to answer any questions you may have, big or small.
His daily duties include answering the phones (always with a smile in his voice), writing up work orders, ordering parts, greeting customers, and making sure our technicians have everything they need to keep the shop running efficiently.
When Bill is not at the shop working, he enjoys spending time with his girlfriend, cooking, and boating.

William Siegle, Technician
Will’s love of cars led him to become a professional technician and he has been dedicated to furthering his automotive knowledge through ongoing training.
Will has a passion for animals too. In fact, he and his girlfriend volunteer all of their spare time to Rescue Ridge, a not-for-profit, no-kill animal rescue center.